Beyond the Borden Axe: 3 Must-Watch True Crime Dramas on Netflix After 'The Lizzie Borden Story'
This post has no video
The Allure of the 'Monster' Anthology
Directors Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan have mastered the art of the psychological deep-dive with their 'Monster' series on Netflix. By blending historical facts with dramatic flair, they have created a true-crime anthology that doesn't just recount murders, but dissects the twisted psychology of the perpetrators. Their latest venture, 'The Lizzie Borden Story,' has rapidly ascended to the #1 spot on the Netflix Top 10, captivating audiences with its portrayal of 19th-century paranoia and domestic horror.
Once you've finished binging the tragic and controversial tale of the Borden household, the void left by such a high-tension drama can be hard to fill. Fortunately, Netflix's library is a treasure trove of courtroom battles, forensic breakthroughs, and family dynastic collapses. If you are craving more content where the truth is elusive and the stakes are life and death, these three recommendations are your next obsession.
1. Alias Grace: A Study in Unreliable Memory
The Vibe: 19th-century atmospheric dread, complex unreliable narrators, and a searing look at Victorian gender roles.
Based on the acclaimed novel by Margaret Atwood, 'Alias Grace' is a cinematic companion to 'The Lizzie Borden Story.' It dramatizes the real-life 1843 case of Grace Marks, a poor Irish immigrant working as a domestic servant in Canada. Grace was convicted of the brutal murder of her employer and his housekeeper—a crime that also saw a male stable hand hanged for his involvement.
The narrative unfolds years later through the eyes of a psychiatrist tasked with assessing Grace's mental state. As she recounts her history, the viewer is left to wonder: Is Grace a traumatized victim of circumstance, or a calculating mastermind who manipulated everyone around her? Much like the Borden case, 'Alias Grace' explores how social constraints and class prejudices shape the narrative of a crime, making it a perfect follow-up for those who enjoy historical mysteries.
2. Mindhunter: The Architecture of a Killer's Mind
The Vibe: A slow-burning, cerebral psychological thriller where the tension lies in the dialogue rather than the bloodshed.
If the psychological profiling in the 'Monster' series fascinated you, 'Mindhunter' is essential viewing. Set in the late 1970s, the series follows two FBI agents who realize that to catch serial killers, they must first understand how they think. They pioneer the field of criminal profiling by interviewing incarcerated murderers to map the behavioral patterns of violence.
Unlike many true-crime shows that rely on gore, 'Mindhunter' finds its horror in the quiet, analytical conversations between the agents and the killers. The cinematography is clinical and precise, reflecting the agents' attempt to bring order to madness. It is a series to be savored, focusing on the intellectual toll that studying darkness takes on the human soul. For fans of deep-dive character studies, this is the gold standard of the genre.
3. The Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal
The Vibe: A sprawling, jaw-dropping saga of familial dysfunction, legal corruption, and a dynasty in freefall.
For those who prefer a more documentary-style approach without sacrificing the drama, 'The Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal' is a powerhouse of a series. While 'Lizzie Borden' looks at a specific crime, this docuseries unravels a generational web of secrets surrounding one of South Carolina's most powerful legal families.
The series connects the dots between the mysterious 2019 death of Mallory Beach, the shocking 2021 murders of Maggie and Paul Murdaugh, and the subsequent fall of the patriarch, Alex Murdaugh. It is a masterclass in how power can be used to shield crime for decades until the house of cards finally collapses. With its heavy focus on courtroom drama and the unraveling of a family's public image, it echoes the same themes of scandal and betrayal found in the Borden story.
Conclusion: Where to Go From Here?
Whether you prefer the gothic atmosphere of the 1800s, the analytical precision of the FBI, or the modern decay of a Southern dynasty, Netflix offers a wide spectrum of true-crime storytelling. 'The Lizzie Borden Story' may have started your current binge, but these three series ensure that your exploration of the human shadow continues.