Prime Video Top 10 Movies: 3 Hidden Gems to Watch This Week (Oct. 5-11)

Navigating the vast library of streaming services can often feel like an endless chore, with the 'trending' lists frequently packed with titles that don't quite deliver. At Tom's Guide, we do the heavy lifting for you by sifting through the noise of the current Prime Video top 10 to find the movies actually worth your precious downtime.

The Best of the Week's Prime Video Top 10

While the algorithm-driven popularity chart is currently dominated by a variety of high-profile releases, not every title is a masterpiece. To ensure you don't waste your evening, we've curated three specific recommendations from this week's most-watched list—ranging from high-stakes heist thrills to iconic cinematic classics.

1. 'Now You See Me: Now You Don't' (2025)

Despite an admittedly questionable title choice for the third installment of this illusion-themed heist franchise, the movie itself is a surprisingly breezy watch. Ten years after the events of the previous film, the core group of thieving magicians—including Jesse Eisenberg and Woody Harrelson—return for a globe-trotting caper that touches on the modern anxiety surrounding deepfakes. It is an unpretentious, fast-paced 112-minute ride that leans into its own silliness, guided by the stylish direction of Ruben Fleischer.

2. 'Once Upon a Time... in Hollywood' (2019)

Quentin Tarantino’s ninth feature film remains a standout in his filmography and features arguably the best performance of Leonardo DiCaprio’s career. As an over-the-hill Western actor, DiCaprio perfectly balances the humor and tragedy of Hollywood's transition period, supported by Brad Pitt’s exceptionally cool stuntman, Cliff Booth. Between the sharp script, the tension, and the satisfyingly explosive finale, it is a heartfelt, violent, and vibrant love letter to a bygone era of cinema.

3. 'Jack Reacher' (2012)

Before the current Prime Video series brought a new iteration to the screen, Tom Cruise defined the character in this gritty, grounded thriller. Directed by Christopher McQuarrie, the film focuses on a methodical investigation following a shocking act of violence in Pittsburgh. Cruise delivers an intense, focused performance that relies on superb choreography and sharp dialogue rather than the over-the-top bombast often found in modern action films. With a brilliant supporting performance from the late Robert Duvall, this is a masterclass in the 'smart thriller' subgenre.

Current Prime Video Top 10 Movies

For those curious about what else is trending, the current top 10 list includes:

1. Now You See Me: Now You Don't (2025)
2. The Love Hypothesis (2026)
3. Jack Reacher: Never Go Back (2016)
4. Once Upon a Time... in Hollywood (2019)
5. Jack Reacher (2012)
6. The Amateur (2025)
7. Livestream from Hell (2026)
8. Good Fortune (2025)
9. Masters of the Universe (2026)
10. Looking Through Water (2025)